Review: Merry and Bright by Jill Shalvis

merry and bright

Merry and Bright
Author: Jill Shalvis
Published: 2013
Genre: Contemporary Romance
Series: N/A
Rating: C

Merry and Bright by Jill Shalvis is a collection of three short stories set around Christmas. I don’t normally read holiday setting books, but I picked this one up for the Ho Ho Ho Read-a-thon.

I’ve only ever read one other book by Shalvis and this collection reminded me why I never picked-up another. While the stories aren’t bad, they’re just not my thing. If I read a contemporary romance, I tend to want the conflict to stay at believable levels.The fact that Shalvis seems to think that all her stories need a conspiracy or life and death situation annoys me.

The first story Finding Mr. Right was the best story in the collection.  Chemist Maggie Bell has a crush on the contractor working outside of her office. Even though she knows he’s completely wrong for her, she decides to pursue him for a short term relationship.

Maggie has the habit of spewing out random facts when nervous. At first I liked this, but the character trait was overused to the point where it started to get annoying. Even though Maggie’s wikipedia knowledge started to get on my nerves, I still liked her character. I only wish that Shalvis had stuck with character conflict between the heroine and hero to move the plot forward, rather than going the action/conspiracy route.

The second story, Bah, Handsome, features Hope, a B&B owner, who owes a ton of money to her loan shark step brother. When one of her step brother’s lackeys shows up at the B&B, Hope doesn’t expect to be attracted to the man. This one really didn’t work well for me. Hope was annoyingly stubborn and I honestly didn’t care at all about the relationship. I also really hated how meddlesome her friends were.

The final story, Ms. Humbug, focuses on city planner, Cami, who discovers the man she’s dating is banging the office assistant. Disheartened, she takes up with mayor and long time verbal sparring partner, Matt. Another story that would’ve worked better for me if Shalvis hadn’t taken the action/conspiracy route. While this one wasn’t bad, I thought the characters were the most underdeveloped, compared to the first two stories. Despite this, I still generally enjoyed the lighthearted tone and bickering between the main characters.

Shalvis has an engaging writing style and her characters are fun, so I can see why her novels are so popular. However, she’s not for me.  If you’re looking for a cute holiday read and are a fan of Shalvis, this is probably worth checking out.

5 thoughts on “Review: Merry and Bright by Jill Shalvis

    • Hi Kate! I’m glad to hear you’re a fan! I’m sad that her books aren’t working for me. Her writing style is a lot of fun.

      I just wish her stories didn’t take such crazy turns. If you know one of her books that was great that didn’t include a huge disaster (like a fire) or a life and death situation near the end, I would love for a recommendation!


    • It does indeed and that’s right up my alley! I love anthologies. Especially when all the stories are by one author so there’s no adjusting to a different writing style when you move onto the next story in the collection. 🙂


  1. Pingback: Sunday Post: November 22 | Book Minx Reads

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s